Can an AI decide about me, and what are my rights when an algorithm says no?
When a computer alone may decide about you in the EU, your right to a human review and an explanation, what courts said, Italy's rules and a request to copy.
AI-generated image: Internet of Things News / OpenAI ChatGPT
After reading this article you will be able to:
- Tell when a decision about you counts as made by a computer alone under EU law
- Ask a company for a human review and a clear explanation, using the request text on this page
- Know where to complain in Italy and in other EU countries if the answer does not come
Drafted with AI from primary sources · checked by a separate AI agent · spot-checked by our editors · How we check
On this page
- What counts as a decision “made by an algorithm”?
- What rights does the GDPR give you?
- Does the AI Act add a right to an explanation?
- Where does this happen in daily life?
- What are the rules in Italy?
- How do you ask for a human review and an explanation?
- Where does this answer stop?
- Where to go next
- Common questions
In the European Union, a computer program alone may take a decision that seriously affects you, such as refusing a loan, a job or a public benefit, only in a few cases the law allows, and even then you can ask for a person to look at it again and for an explanation of how it was reached. Whether the company calls its program “AI”, “an algorithm” or “a score” makes no difference: what counts is whether a person really weighed your case.
These rights come mainly from the GDPR, the EU data protection law; the AI Act adds one for some decisions. Every law and ruling below was checked against official sources on 15 November 2026. This page is not legal advice.
What counts as a decision “made by an algorithm”?
Article 22 of the GDPR covers decisions “based solely on automated processing” (made by a computer, with no person deciding) that produce “legal effects” on you or “similarly significantly” affect you. The GDPR’s own examples, in its introduction (recital 71), are the “automatic refusal of an online credit application” and “e-recruiting practices without any human intervention”.
A rubber stamp does not change this. The guidelines of the EU data protection authorities (WP251rev.01, revised 6 February 2018) say an employee who routinely approves whatever the computer says does not count: the check must come from someone with “the authority and competence to change the decision”.
What rights does the GDPR give you?
Article 22 allows a decision made by a computer alone only if it is necessary for a contract with you, if an EU or national law allows it with safeguards, or if you gave your explicit consent. In the contract and consent cases, the company must give you at least the right to obtain human intervention (a person who looks at it again), to express your point of view and to contest the decision.
You also have the right to be told. When it collects your data (Articles 13 and 14), and whenever you ask (Article 15), a company must say whether it takes such decisions and give “meaningful information about the logic involved” and the consequences for you. Under Article 12 the answer is free and due within one month, or three if the company explains within the first month why it needs longer.
Two rulings of the EU Court of Justice explain this:
- SCHUFA, case C-634/21, 7 December 2023. SCHUFA, a German credit agency, sells banks scores on how likely people are to repay. The Court ruled that when a bank “draws strongly” on such a score, calculated by computer, to give you credit or not, the score itself is an automated decision under Article 22, “prohibited in principle” in the words of the press release. The German court had to check whether German law allows an exception.
- Dun & Bradstreet Austria, case C-203/22, 27 February 2025. A phone company refused a woman a €10-a-month contract after Dun & Bradstreet’s automated credit check. The Court ruled that you can require a short, understandable explanation of “the procedure and principles actually applied”, showing which of your data were used and how. A complex formula or the algorithm is not enough; the press release adds that it may help to say how a change in your data would have changed the result. If the company claims a trade secret, it must show the information to the authority or court, which decides what you can see.
Does the AI Act add a right to an explanation?
For some decisions. Article 86 of the AI Act gives you the right to “clear and meaningful explanations of the role of the AI system” and of the main elements of a decision based on what a high-risk AI system produced, when it seriously affects your health, safety or fundamental rights. Unlike the GDPR rule, it also covers decisions a person took with the AI’s help.
High-risk systems are listed in Annex III of the AI Act: among them, AI that gives you a credit score, prices life and health insurance, filters job applications, assigns tasks to or evaluates workers, and checks who can get public benefits.
Article 86 has applied since 2 August 2026, the AI Act’s main start date; the Digital Omnibus on AI, a 2026 law that changed some AI Act dates, did not move it. But the Omnibus delayed the main rules for the systems on that list to 2 December 2027, and Article 86 applies only where EU law does not already give the same right. For now, the GDPR rights are the firmer ones.
Where does this happen in daily life?
| Where | Example | Rules that apply |
|---|---|---|
| Loans and credit | A bank or phone company says no after a credit score | GDPR and the two rulings above; AI Act high-risk |
| Insurance | A price or a refusal for life or health insurance | GDPR; AI Act high-risk |
| Hiring | Software filters out your CV before anyone reads it | GDPR; AI Act high-risk |
| Platform work | A delivery app blocks a rider’s account or gives fewer shifts | GDPR; AI Act high-risk |
| Public offices | A program assigns teachers to schools or checks who gets a benefit | GDPR and national law; AI Act high-risk for benefits |
What are the rules in Italy?
Delivery riders. Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, fined Foodinho, a Glovo group company, €2.6 million on 10 June 2021, partly because riders could not obtain human intervention or contest decisions taken by algorithms. On 22 July 2021 it fined Deliveroo Italy €2.5 million, among other reasons for breaking Article 22(3). On 13 November 2024 it fined Foodinho €5 million, partly because blocked riders got an automatic message that did not say they could contest it, and ordered that the algorithm’s decisions be checked by trained staff.
At work. Article 1-bis of decree 152/1997, added by the 2022 “Decreto Trasparenza” (d.lgs. 104/2022), obliges employers to tell workers, before the work starts, when they use fully automated systems (the wording in force since 5 May 2023) to hire, manage, monitor, evaluate or dismiss them, and how those systems work. Workers or unions can ask for more and must get a written answer within 30 days. Systems protected by industrial or commercial secrecy are excluded. Article 11 of Law 132/2025 on AI, in force since 10 October 2025, applies this duty to AI and says AI at work must respect workers’ rights without discrimination.
Public offices. In ruling no. 8472 of 13 December 2019, on an algorithm that ran a national transfer of teachers ordered in 2016, the Consiglio di Stato, Italy’s highest court for cases against public offices, ruled against the Ministry: a public office’s algorithm must be knowable and understandable, a person must be able to check and overturn its result, and it must not discriminate. Article 14 of Law 132/2025 now says AI in public offices only supports the work, and the person who decides remains the only one responsible.
How do you ask for a human review and an explanation?
- Find who decided. Ask the company that said no whether it used a score from another company, such as a credit agency. You can send the same request to both.
- Write to the privacy contact given in the company’s privacy policy. The Garante says no special form is needed: an email or a registered letter will do. Keep a copy.
- Copy and fill in this model (it is not legal advice):
Subject: Request under Articles 15 and 22 of the GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679)
On [date] you [refused my loan / blocked my account / rejected my application], reference [number]. Under Article 15 of the GDPR, please tell me: (1) whether this decision was based solely on automated processing, including profiling; (2) if so, meaningful information about the logic involved: which of my personal data were used, how, and what would have changed the result; (3) whether you used a score from another company, and which; (4) a copy of my personal data used for this decision. If the decision was automated, under Article 22(3) I ask for a review by a person with the authority to change it, and I contest it because: [your reasons]. Please answer within one month (Article 12(3)).
[Name, address, date, signature]
- Wait one month (three, if the company tells you it needs more time).
- If the answer is late or unsatisfactory, file a free complaint with the Garante on its model, by certified email (PEC) to [email protected], by registered letter to Piazza Venezia 11, 00187 Rome, or by hand; with a handwritten signature, attach a copy of your ID. Elsewhere in the EU, the European Data Protection Board lists each national authority. You can also go to court.
Where does this answer stop?
- Exceptions exist. A national law can allow automated decisions or limit these rights, and a company can argue that a person did decide. For a dispute, ask a lawyer or a consumer association.
- Rules may change. On 19 November 2025 the Commission proposed rewriting part of Article 22. On 15 November 2026 the European Parliament’s procedure file still showed it at committee stage.
- Decisions, not appeals. This page reports what the Garante and the courts decided, not how any later appeal ended.
- Outside the EU, other rules apply.
Where to go next
- AI for everyone: what AI is and how to start using it safely.
- What happens to what you type into ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude?: your rights to see and delete your data.
- Will AI take my job?: what the studies say about AI and work.
Common questions
Can a bank refuse my loan because of a computer score?
It can use a score, but in the EU it cannot let the computer decide alone except in the cases the GDPR allows, and then you can ask for a person to review the decision. The EU Court of Justice ruled in December 2023 that a score from a credit agency counts as an automated decision when the bank relies strongly on it, so the agency must respect these rules too.
Do I have the right to know why an algorithm rejected me?
Yes, when the decision was taken by a computer alone. Under Article 15 of the GDPR you can ask for meaningful information about the logic involved. In February 2025 the EU Court of Justice said this means an explanation you can understand of which of your data were used and how, not a mathematical formula.
Can a company reject my job application using AI?
It can use software to help, but a rejection made by a program with no real human check is the kind of decision the GDPR restricts; the GDPR's own text gives 'e-recruiting practices without any human intervention' as an example. In Italy, employers must also tell workers when they use fully automated systems to hire, manage or evaluate them.
Where do I complain about an automated decision in Italy?
First write to the company and wait one month. If the answer is late or unsatisfactory, you can file a free complaint with the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali by certified email (PEC) to [email protected], by registered letter or by hand, using the model on its complaint page. You can also go to court.
Does the AI Act give me a right to an explanation?
For some decisions, yes. Article 86 of the AI Act, in force since 2 August 2026, gives a right to a clear explanation of the role the AI played when a decision with serious effects on you was based on a high-risk AI system, such as credit scoring or hiring software. The main rules for those systems start only on 2 December 2027, and where the GDPR already gives you an explanation, the GDPR applies.
Topics: Who answers?, GDPR, AI Act, rights, Italy